Silver Screen Library 

What the Night Brings by Mark Billingham - Review





Click Here to Join Our Mailing List Button

Follow Us:

Twitter Icon
Facebook Icon
LinkedIn Icon
Goodreads Icon
Photo of Mark Billingham

Mark Billingham



Atlantic Monthly Press

432 Pages

Amazon.com (E-Book)

Amazon.com (Hardcover)



B+


What the Night Brings Cover

One joy of reading detective fiction is following the characters in a long-running series. Besides solving individual crimes, they age, marry, raise families, divorce, retire, and sometimes die over the course of the series. The best example of this phenomenon is Ed McBain’s 87th Precinct series, which followed Detective Steve Carella and his cohorts through 55 novels in nearly 50 years. Great Britain has its version of the 87th Precinct in Mark Billingham’s D.I. Tom Thorne series. Thorne and his fellow coppers (the term they use to describe each other) solve cases while leading rich personal lives. The most recent Thorne novel, What the Night Brings, the 19th in the series, is an excellent procedural. However, those unfamiliar with the previous books, like me, probably won’t get the same level of enjoyment.


What the Night Brings begins with a ghoulishly ironic murder, or, more precisely, four murders. Four police officers die from eating poisoned doughnuts from a box that was supposedly left as a gift at a crime scene. Thorne might have become victim number five, but the box only held four doughnuts. Needless to say, solving the case becomes a top priority for the Met Police. The case gets more complicated and more sensational when two 

more murders follow, a police officer and a recently retired officer. Thorne and his team realize the deaths are the work of a serial killer.

The author set this novel against a background of widespread police corruption, and not just the familiar “police-on-the-take” variety. Instead, the author’s fictional version of the Met Police has been rocked by a series of high-profile cases of officers committing and usually getting away with brutal crimes, primarily rapes. (What the Night Brings was inspired by a recent sensational real-life murder case in Great Britain.) The serial killer Thorne’s team is pursuing wants vengeance against officers who have gotten away with vicious rapes. Thorne also discovers that the victims in his case are connected in a way that suggests the case is much more complex than it first seems.


What the Night Brings is a well-crafted procedural, combining solid 21st-century police work with some inspired deduction by the very perceptive Thorne. He and his partner, Nicola Tanner, employ the services of a brilliant hacker (a de rigeur member of any modern-day fictional police force) to uncover a significant lead. Thorne finally has a flash of inspiration while at a weekend department barbecue (featuring overcooked sausage and undercooked chicken) that allows his team to catch the killer.


My reference to sausage and chicken is one of the many examples of humor in What the Night Brings. The book’s various storylines are often grim and depressing, but the author frequently livens them up with wit. None of the characters are outright buffoons, but some have traits the author exploits for laughter. For example, the gay pathologist has a boyfriend but always seems to be on the prowl for new hookups. And, as in any close-knit team, most of the back-and-forth banter involves people laughing with each other rather than at each other.


The novel’s humor is only one aspect of the ongoing character development in What the Night Brings. Several characters, including Thorne, have appeared in the series since the start, and they continue to develop here. The author specifically cautioned readers against revealing spoilers, and I won’t. However, several characters make significant decisions in the book, making them more fully developed. Two characters who appear in the series for the first time—the killer and an eyewitness—also have fully developed personalities in just a handful of chapters, thanks to the author’s skillful writing.


These well-rounded characters and their detailed life stories are a major strength of What the Night Brings. However, they made it more difficult for me to follow the story at first. This book was the first Thorne novel I’ve read. I was confused at times by references to backstories and by the use of British slang terms with which I was unfamiliar. Sometimes, I quickly picked up that Thorne watched soccer matches in his spare time instead of American football games, but some of the food the author described puzzled me. When the investigation kicked into high gear, though, I could follow the developments easily. Still, I didn’t have the emotional connection to characters that readers who have already read several books in the series will have. As a result, some surprising events had less of an impact on me than I’m sure they will have on others.


I have read some five-star reviews of What the Night Brings, and I understand what dedicated series fans may have felt, which in part led to that rating. However, I can only review a book as I experience it, not how others might. I greatly enjoyed What the Night Brings, but the first few chapters were somewhat confusing. As a police procedural with a good dose of humor and a grim storyline, this novel was one of the best of its type I’ve read in some time. As a complete dramatic experience, it was a bit less powerful; hence, a four-star rating from me.


NOTE: The publisher graciously provided me with a copy of this book through NetGalley. However, the decision to review the book and the contents of this review are entirely my own.


In this clip, author Mark Billingham discusses What the Night Brings with Sam Brownley of the UKcrimebook Club:


Mark Billingham is one of the UK's most acclaimed and popular crime writers. He has written over 30 novels, including 19 featuring D.I. Tom Thorne. Billingham’s Thorne novels have won seven Crime Novel of the Year Awards and a Sherlock Award for Best British Detective. He has also been nominated for seven CWA Daggers. Billingham’s thriller, In the Dark, was chosen as one of 12 best books of the year by the Times and his debut novel Sleepyhead was chosen by the Sunday Times as one of the 100 books that had shaped the decade. Each of his novels has been a Sunday Times Top Ten bestseller.


Billingham is also a former actor, television writer, and stand-up comedian. A television series based on the Thorne novels, starring David Morrissey as Thorne, aired in 2010  Another BBC series based on his works aired in 2017.


Buy other Mark Billingham books on Amazon:

Sleepyhead Cover
The Last Dance Cover
Die of Shame Cover

Header Photo: "Riot Radio" by Arielle Calderon / Flickr / CC By / Cropped

Silver Screen Video Banner Photos:  pedrojperez / Morguefilewintersixfour / Morguefile

Join Button: "Film Element" by Stockphotosforfree

Twitter Icon: "Twitter Icon" by Freepik

Facebook Icon: "Facebook Icon" by Freepik

LinkedIn Icon: "LinkedIn Icon" by Fathema Khanom / Freepik

Goodreads Icon: "Letter G Icon" by arnikahossain / Freepik

Certain images on this site appear courtesy of Amazon.com and other sponsors of Silver Screen Videos for the purpose of advertising products on those sites. Silver Screen Videos earns commissions from purchases on those sites.  

 

© 2025 Steven R. Silver. All rights reserved.   

Click to Learn More about Network Solutions