Silver Screen Cinema

Here Review





Click Here to Join Our Mailing List Button

Follow Us:

Twitter Icon
Facebook Icon
LinkedIn Icon
Goodreads Icon
Photo of Tom Hanks

Tom Hanks



Sony Pictures Releasing

Rated: PG-13

104 Minutes

Directed by: Robert Zemeckis

Starring: Tom Hanks; Robin Wright


C


Here Streaming

Movies have employed gimmicks since the dawn of filmmaking. Sound and color movies were originally gimmicks. Usually, the gimmick is just one aspect of the movie, like a 3D film. But, occasionally, a gimmick rises from being part of a film to being the entire reason for the movie.


A half-century ago, I saw a drive-in movie (the 70s equivalent of direct-to-video or streaming) entitled Wicked, Wicked. It was a routine slasher film about a killer with a large knife stalking women at a fancy resort. However, I remember the movie because it was filmed in a technique called “duovision.” The screen was divided in half, with a line down the middle. Each side showed a different picture at the same time. Thus, the camera could feature close-ups of the faces of both parties in a conversation. More relevant for this genre, the camera showed both the stalking killer and the unwary victim-to-be at the same time. Did it work? Not really; the movie was mediocre at best and hard to find on video today. But I still remember the film a half-century later.


Technology has improved in the intervening 50 years, but the gimmick movie is still with us. Instead of a drive-in thriller with a B-movie cast and crew, the 2024 version of the concept, Here, features a cast and crew with impeccable credentials. Tom Hanks

and Robin Wright headline the film, which was directed by Robert Zemeckis and features a screenplay by Eric Roth. Zemeckis is familiar with movie gimmickry, as his Who Framed Roger Rabbit? may be the concept’s most innovative and successful example. Zemeckis and the other principals of Here joined forces 30 years ago for the Oscar-winning Forrest Gump and try to recreate that magic. However, the result is a mediocre failure, just like Wicked, Wicked from a half-century earlier.


Here takes place in a single location with a camera that uses the same point of view for 104 minutes of real time and millions of years of reel time. The audience first sees a two-minute clip showing evolution from the dinosaurs through Native Americans who lived on the land to Ben Franklin’s son, who built a home across the street from the camera location. That location becomes the rear of the living room inside a house built during World War I. Most of the movie focuses on the various families living there.


After World War II, Al Young (Paul Bettany), a returning veteran, and his wife, Rose (Kelly Reilly), buy the house. Al has PTSD and soon becomes an alcoholic, but he still earns a living as a salesman. The couple have three children. The oldest, Richard (Hanks plays the character as a teenager and subsequently), remains in the house after his girlfriend, Margaret (Wright), becomes pregnant, and they soon marry. Over the years, Richard, who has talent as an artist, repeatedly talks about buying his own home, but he never does. Instead, he becomes a salesman like his father.

The Young family’s story would make a good limited series spread over six to eight hours. Instead, Here tries to shoehorn it into about one hour of screen time. The rest of the movie covers the various other families that live in the house (or nearby, in the case of Ben Franklin’s son). Further, the film doesn’t proceed in chronological order. Instead, scenes about prior residents are inserted, seemingly at random, into the Youngs’ storyline. The effect isn’t confusing because the time shifts are easy to follow. However, they prevent the audience from becoming more involved in the Youngs’ story.


When Here covers critical emotional events in the Young family’s lives, it does so in a superficial, blink-and-you’ll-miss-it manner. For example, Richard’s younger brother, Jimmy (Harry Marcus), enlists in the Navy during the Vietnam War. This decision causes considerable friction in the family, especially with Al, who has bitter memories of his own military service. However, the event passes in one brief scene, and the only further mention of Jimmy’s decision or career is an occasional shot of him in uniform later in the film. The movie’s ultimate emotional moment, Richard’s realization that he should have followed his heart instead of conventional responsibilities, is apparent to audiences long before Richard realizes it.


Although the Youngs have the most screen time, they aren’t the most interesting family in Here. That honor goes to Lee and Stella Beekman (David Fynn and Ophelia Lovibond), who own the house immediately prior to Al and Rose. Lee is a tinkerer who invents a reclining chair his investors rename the “La-Z-Boy.” Their ten minutes of screen time provide more humor and genuine emotion (the couple gets frisky on the La-Z-Boy often) than the rest of the movie combined.


When the Beekmans aren’t on-screen, Here spends more time depicting the passage of time through changes in clothing, furniture, and electronic accessories. And, since the house has a large picture window that is never covered by curtains or blinds, the audience can see their front lawn and the houses across the street over time. A few faddish styles are mildly interesting, but the constant change in décor becomes annoying.


The movie’s use of de-aging technology is even more annoying. Instead of casting younger actors as Richard and Margaret in their teens and 20s, the movie digitally de-ages Hanks and Wright. Tom Hanks thus looks like a wax statue of his character from the Bosom Buddies TV series. For the movie’s last scenes, the filmmakers employ a similar aging technology to make Hanks and Wright appear in their 80s.


Despite all the failed gimmickry, Here is occasionally effective. The lead actors take their roles seriously, and Paul Bettany is excellent as an embittered World War II veteran who stays embittered for the next half-century. As Al and the other main characters grow older, the physical and mental infirmities of old age get to them, and the subsequent scenes are sometimes quite touching. Unfortunately, whenever an emotional moment occurs, it’s often over before the audience has the proper opportunity to process it.


Take away the distractions of the other families, bizarre de-aging, and décor changes, and Here is a one-act play with an excellent cast covering one family’s lives over 70 years. The actors prevent Here from becoming a bad Saturday Night Live sketch but can’t save the film. What could have been a terrific limited series with a better script becomes an unsuccessful exercise in experimental filmmaking. 


In this clip, Tom Hanks, Robin Wright, and Robert Zemeckis discuss making Here:


Watch Robert Zemeckis movies on Amazon Prime Video:

Forrest Gump Streaming
Back to the Future Streaming
Cast Away Streaming

Header Photo: "Riot Radio" by Arielle Calderon / Flickr / CC By / Cropped

Silver Screen Cinema Banner Photos:  pedrojperez / Morguefilewintersixfour / Morguefile

Join Button: "Film Element" by Stockphotosforfree

Twitter Icon: "Twitter Icon" by Freepik

Facebook Icon: "Facebook Icon" by Freepik

LinkedIn Icon: "LinkedIn Icon" by Fathema Khanom / Freepik

Goodreads Icon: "Letter G Icon" by arnikahossain / Freepik

Tom Hanks: "25tth International Film Festival: Tom Hanks" by Dick Thomas Johnson / Flickr CC BY 2.0

Certain images on this site appear courtesy of Amazon.com and other sponsors of Silver Screen Videos for the purpose of advertising products on those sites. Silver Screen Videos earns commissions from purchases on those sites.  

 

© 2024 Steven R. Silver. All rights reserved.   

Click to Learn More about Network Solutions