Share This Article:
Return to Silver Screen Central Home page
BFormer Speaker of the House Tip O’Neill noted that “all politics is local,” an observation that is at the heart of Freeheld. A dying woman wants to ensure that her pension benefits go to the love of her life, but because that lover is also female, a seemingly simple request becomes a focus of the Gay Rights movement.
Freeheld, based on an Oscar-winning 2007 documentary of the same name, is the story of longtime Ocean County, NJ, detective Laurel Hester (Julianne Moore), who kept her sexuality secret from her co-workers even after entering into a domestic partnership with a younger woman, Stacie Andrade (Ellen Page). When Laurel develops terminal cancer, she discovers that Stacie can’t receive the same pension benefits a married spouse could. So, with the help of outside activists, she and Stacie try to persuade the county Board of Freeholders to change their minds.
There is a deeply personal, tragic love story at the heart of Freeheld, featuring an excellent, understated performance by Ellen Page. The movie’s emphasis, however, is not on that love story or on the morality or legality of gay marriage in general, but rather on the political process involved in the decision whether or not to grant Stacie Laurel’s pension. So, as Laurel’s conditions worsens, she and Stacie fade into the background, and the film spends most of its time showing Laurel’s straight partner (Michael Shannon) and a gay activist (Steve Carell) trying to lobby the Freeholders, most notably a conscience-stricken Josh Charles, to change their minds. Director Peter Sollett is never able to make the political story in Freeheld as compelling as the emotional one except at the very end, where, a wheelchair-bound Laurel, just days from death, pleads her case in person. Further, Carell’s in-your-face performance, even if it’s historically accurate, is badly out of step with the rest of the movie. Still, in the wake of the recent Supreme Court decision of gay marriage, Freehold illustrates the often fascinating story of one of the hundreds of individual local ordinances and court decisions that created the political and moral climate in which the Supreme Court found itself.
Continue reading on Freeheld: Mini-review
Recent Comments